On the other hand, a request for narcotics to treat chronic tension headaches should not be honoured if the physician believes an alternative treatment is more appropriate. Log in via Institution. In any other case there seems to be no ethical justification for PMSP. Intensive care specialists can be confronted with a request for peri- or postmortem sperm procurement, while not being aware of the country-specific provisions. The latter claim is based on the view that sometimes it can make sense to say that a child is worse off than she would have been if she had not been created; namely, when the life is so filled with pain and suffering that these negative experiences greatly overshadow any pleasurable or other positive experiences the child might have. Bahar Gholipour, Staff Writer Bahar Gholipour is a staff reporter for Live Science covering neuroscience, odd medical cases and all things health.
Ethics of postmortem sperm retrieval | Human Reproduction | Oxford Academic
Mrs Roberts is not the first widow to become pregnant using her late husband's frozen sperm. In the United Kingdom, it is not allowed unless the man has given prior written consent. Various methods for retrieving spermatozoa have been described, including surgical excision of the epididymis Rothman, , irrigation or aspiration of the vas deferens Kerr et al. To illustrate, consider a hypothetical situation in which a woman requesting donor insemination DI is an unreformed alcoholic.
Because her husband gave his permission, however, she avoided the legal anguish of the Diane Blood case. Support Center Support Center. A practical problem in obtaining and documenting this agreement arises because freezing within 24 h after cardiac standstill is optimal for sperm viability. A fourth option is rectal probe ejaculation, also known as electroejaculation. James Robert, who died from cancer at 33, had always dreamed of adding to his family.
Returning from a night of drinking, Nikolas and a friend were attacked on their way to catch a bus ride home. Intensive care specialists can be confronted with a request for peri- or postmortem sperm procurement, while not being aware of the country-specific provisions. Conclusion Although a request for PMSP will remain a rare event on the ICU, intensive care specialists should be aware of the practical and legal issues involved, since the decision whether or not to proceed with PMSP can only be taken in a relatively short time-window. Moreover, the principle of conscientious objection would be applicable; a physician who conscientiously opposes such sperm retrieval is free to decline to perform it. That to me is the true value. Another legal issue involves inheritance.